Teenage substitute Mo Fadera grabbed the headlines and the goal that sent this dramatic tie to a replay.
This was the first ever meeting between the sides and now they’ll meet again in four days.
Heaton looked to be turning the form book on its head when they led through a Leighton Hopper first half penalty and Garforth lost Harry Viggars to a red card, but there was a major turnaround when the home side introduced three strikers from the bench.
Both sides had hit the woodwork before seventeen year old Fadera levelled the scores on eighty nine minutes.
There was still time for even later drama when Sam Barker forced a save from Lewis Brass right on the final whistle.