A train carriage full of Garforth supporters couldn't inspire Garforth to an away victory, as two second half goals gave North Ferriby the win.
A fairly even, goalless first half saw the sides go level in at half time, but the match was all but over within the space of four second half minutes.
Josh Whiteleys' sixty first minute spot kick was followed up on sixty four minutes with a goal by Charlie Clements.
Garforth next have two home games to concentrate on.
Newton Aycliffe are the visitors on Tuesday 30th September (7.45pm kick-off), then Redcar Athletic come to the Bannister Prentice Stadium on Saturday 4th October (3pm kick-off).